Argumentative Essay Rubric
For argumentative and persuasive essays. Scores the claim, the evidence, the reasoning with a counterargument, and the writing.
| Criteria | Excellent (4) | Good (3) | Fair (2) | Needs work (1) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Claim | Arguable, precise claim stated early. | Clear claim, somewhat general. | Claim is unclear or not arguable. | No claim. |
| Evidence | Strong, credible, cited evidence for every reason. | Credible evidence for most reasons. | Some evidence is weak, personal or uncited. | Little or no evidence. |
| Reasoning | Explains clearly why the evidence proves the claim. | Explains most links between evidence and claim. | Reasoning is thin or jumps to conclusions. | No reasoning. |
| Counterargument | States a fair opposing view and rebuts it with evidence. | States an opposing view and responds to it. | Mentions an opposing view without a response. | No counterargument. |
| Organization and style | Logical structure, formal tone, clean mechanics. | Clear structure, mostly formal, few errors. | Structure or tone slips; noticeable errors. | Disorganized; many errors. |
How to use it
For AP Lang use the 6-point AP structure instead: thesis 1, evidence and commentary 4, sophistication 1.
Total score: 20 points (5 criteria × 4). Convert to a percentage by dividing by 20.
Coming soon
Grade an essay with this rubric
Soon you will paste an essay and get a score for every criterion of this rubric, with quotes from the text.