EssayGrader

Argumentative Essay Rubric

For argumentative and persuasive essays. Scores the claim, the evidence, the reasoning with a counterargument, and the writing.

CriteriaExcellent (4)Good (3)Fair (2)Needs work (1)
ClaimArguable, precise claim stated early.Clear claim, somewhat general.Claim is unclear or not arguable.No claim.
EvidenceStrong, credible, cited evidence for every reason.Credible evidence for most reasons.Some evidence is weak, personal or uncited.Little or no evidence.
ReasoningExplains clearly why the evidence proves the claim.Explains most links between evidence and claim.Reasoning is thin or jumps to conclusions.No reasoning.
CounterargumentStates a fair opposing view and rebuts it with evidence.States an opposing view and responds to it.Mentions an opposing view without a response.No counterargument.
Organization and styleLogical structure, formal tone, clean mechanics.Clear structure, mostly formal, few errors.Structure or tone slips; noticeable errors.Disorganized; many errors.

How to use it

  • For AP Lang use the 6-point AP structure instead: thesis 1, evidence and commentary 4, sophistication 1.

  • Total score: 20 points (5 criteria × 4). Convert to a percentage by dividing by 20.

Coming soon

Grade an essay with this rubric

Soon you will paste an essay and get a score for every criterion of this rubric, with quotes from the text.