College Essay Rubric
For Common App personal statements and supplemental essays. Voice, story, reflection, structure and mechanics.
| Criteria | Excellent (4) | Good (3) | Fair (2) | Needs work (1) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Voice | Sounds like a real person; specific and personal. | Personal, a bit generic in places. | Generic, could be anyone. | No sense of the writer. |
| Story and detail | Concrete moments and sensory detail. | Some concrete moments. | Mostly general statements. | No story. |
| Reflection | Shows growth, values or insight clearly. | Some reflection. | Reflection is tacked on at the end. | No reflection. |
| Structure | Strong opening and ending; within the word limit. | Clear arc, ending is weaker. | Wanders; over the limit. | No arc. |
| Mechanics | Clean grammar and sentences. | A few errors. | Several errors. | Many errors. |
How to use it
Common App personal statements are limited to 650 words.
Total score: 20 points (5 criteria × 4). Convert to a percentage by dividing by 20.
Coming soon
Grade an essay with this rubric
Soon you will paste an essay and get a score for every criterion of this rubric, with quotes from the text.