Essay Rubric
A general essay rubric for middle school, high school and first-year college. Five criteria, four levels, 20 points total.
| Criteria | Excellent (4) | Good (3) | Fair (2) | Needs work (1) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Thesis | Clear, specific thesis that takes a position and guides the whole essay. | Clear thesis, but broad or only partly guides the essay. | Thesis is vague or appears late. | No identifiable thesis. |
| Evidence | Specific, relevant evidence in every body paragraph, sources cited correctly. | Relevant evidence in most paragraphs, minor citation gaps. | Evidence is general or thin in places. | Little or no evidence. |
| Analysis | Explains how each piece of evidence supports the thesis. | Explains most evidence, some summary instead of analysis. | Mostly summary, connections to the thesis are weak. | No analysis. |
| Organization | Logical order, strong introduction and conclusion, smooth transitions. | Clear order, transitions mostly work. | Order is hard to follow in places. | No clear structure. |
| Conventions | Almost no errors in grammar, spelling and punctuation. | A few errors that do not distract. | Errors sometimes get in the way of meaning. | Frequent errors make it hard to read. |
How to use it
Share the rubric with students before they start writing.
Weight Evidence and Analysis double if the assignment is about argument.
Total score: 20 points (5 criteria × 4). Convert to a percentage by dividing by 20.
Coming soon
Grade an essay with this rubric
Soon you will paste an essay and get a score for every criterion of this rubric, with quotes from the text.