EssayGrader

Essay Rubric

A general essay rubric for middle school, high school and first-year college. Five criteria, four levels, 20 points total.

CriteriaExcellent (4)Good (3)Fair (2)Needs work (1)
ThesisClear, specific thesis that takes a position and guides the whole essay.Clear thesis, but broad or only partly guides the essay.Thesis is vague or appears late.No identifiable thesis.
EvidenceSpecific, relevant evidence in every body paragraph, sources cited correctly.Relevant evidence in most paragraphs, minor citation gaps.Evidence is general or thin in places.Little or no evidence.
AnalysisExplains how each piece of evidence supports the thesis.Explains most evidence, some summary instead of analysis.Mostly summary, connections to the thesis are weak.No analysis.
OrganizationLogical order, strong introduction and conclusion, smooth transitions.Clear order, transitions mostly work.Order is hard to follow in places.No clear structure.
ConventionsAlmost no errors in grammar, spelling and punctuation.A few errors that do not distract.Errors sometimes get in the way of meaning.Frequent errors make it hard to read.

How to use it

  • Share the rubric with students before they start writing.

  • Weight Evidence and Analysis double if the assignment is about argument.

  • Total score: 20 points (5 criteria × 4). Convert to a percentage by dividing by 20.

Coming soon

Grade an essay with this rubric

Soon you will paste an essay and get a score for every criterion of this rubric, with quotes from the text.